Skip to content
No results
  • About
    • EDRM Global Advisory Council
    • EDRM Policies
    • Get Involved
    • Awards
    • GO Spirit Award
    • Hub
    • Contact
  • Models & Tools
    • Models
      • EDRM Model
      • Information Governance Reference Model
      • Metrics Model
      • Privacy & Security Risk Reduction Model
    • Datasets
    • Tools
      • Budget Calculators
      • E-Discovery Tools
      • Security Audit Questionnaire
      • eDiscovery Maturity Self-Assessment Test
  • EDRM Wiki
  • Blog
  • EDRM News
    • Above the Fold Newsletter
  • Education
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • Events
    • White Papers
  • Projects
  • Partners
  • Remembering Kaylee
EDRM
  • About
    • EDRM Global Advisory Council
    • EDRM Policies
    • Get Involved
    • Awards
    • GO Spirit Award
    • Hub
    • Contact
  • Models & Tools
    • Models
      • EDRM Model
      • Information Governance Reference Model
      • Metrics Model
      • Privacy & Security Risk Reduction Model
    • Datasets
    • Tools
      • Budget Calculators
      • E-Discovery Tools
      • Security Audit Questionnaire
      • eDiscovery Maturity Self-Assessment Test
  • EDRM Wiki
  • Blog
  • EDRM News
    • Above the Fold Newsletter
  • Education
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • Events
    • White Papers
  • Projects
  • Partners
  • Remembering Kaylee
EDRM

Cautionary AI Metadata Decision

  • Michael D. Berman
  • November 19, 2026
  • AI, AI Ethics, Blog Articles, Case Law, In the News, Lawyers Duties, Metadata, Recent News, Technology
Cautionary AI Metadata Decision
Image: EDRM.

[EDRM Editor’s Note: The opinions and positions are those of Michael D. Berman.]


It may not be a good thing to leave a metadata trail that confirms AI use. Nugent v. Fortress Flooring, Inc., 2026 WL 3217039 (N.D. Ill. Oct. 27, 2026).

The court wrote: “Before addressing the merits of the motion to vacate, the court must discuss some irregularities in defendants’ filings…. [T]he file names of defendants’ briefs strongly suggest that they were written by artificial intelligence (‘AI’), specifically Westlaw’s internal artificial-intelligence platform, ‘CoCounsel.’ Both the motion and the reply bear the file name ‘CoCounsel Skill Results.’ This file name is an exact match for the file name at issue in a recent case in the Sixth Circuit where counsel was reprimanded for filing unverified AI generated documents, United States v. Farris, 171 F.4th 920 (6th Cir. 2026).”

However, Nugent did not involve any hallucinated citations. Instead, “defendants’ two briefs do not cite a single case between them…. The irregularities here suggest that counsel submitted unreviewed or hastily reviewed AI-generated work. The court will take no further action on these irregularities, and the court trusts that counsel will continue to fulfill their legal and ethical obligations in the future.”

For more information on the Sixth Circuit’s Farris decision, please visit “Hallucinations” by West’s CoCounsel? – E-Discovery LLC (Apr. 7, 2026).


Assisted by GAI and LLM Technologies per EDRM’s GAI and LLM Policy.

Author

  • Michael Berman
    Michael D. Berman

    Michael Berman is a practicing lawyer and an adjunct faculty member at the University of Baltimore School of Law.  He has published extensively, including as the editor-in-chief and a contributing author in “Electronically Stored Information in Maryland Courts” (Maryland State Bar Ass’n. 2020), co-editing two American Bar Association books on electronic discovery, as well as co-authoring law review and other articles regarding electronically stored information (“ESI”).  He has presented widely in venues ranging from local to National events and served as a Court Appointed ESI Discovery Supervisor for ESI Protocol.

    View all posts Owner, E-Discovery LLC

Search EDRM

No results

Guardian Partners

Exterro logo

Get Social with Us

Find EDRM on Facebook Follow EDRM on Twitter
Connect with EDRM on LinkedIn View EDRM - Electronic Discovery Reference Model documents on JD Supra

EXCEPT WHERE OTHERWISE NOTED , CONTENT POSTED AT EDRM.NET IS LICENSED UNDER A CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION 4.0 INTERNATIONAL LICENSE. THAT MEANS YOU ARE FREE TO SHARE, REMIX OR MAKE COMMERCIAL USE OF THE CONTENT SO LONG AS YOU PROVIDE ATTRIBUTION. TO PROVIDE ATTRIBUTION, PLEASE CITE TO "EDRM (EDRM.NET)."

THE LICENSE DOES NOT COVER THE NAMES, IMAGES,  LIKENESSES, OR VOICES OF ANY PERSON, INCLUDING AI GENERATED DEPICTIONS, THIRD PARTY MATERIAL SUCH AS SCREENSHOTS, PHOTOGRAPHS, LOGOS AND QUOTED WORKS, CONTENT WHOSE AUTHORS HAVE RESERVED THEIR RIGHTS, OR EDRM'S NAMES AND LOGOS.

IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS, CONTACT US AT INFO@EDRM.NET.

© 2026 EDRM. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. EDRM POLICIES.

Share Your Memories
  • Enter your email address to receive updates.
  • Click to upload a photo (Max Upload Size 1 MB)
  •  

Share Your Memories

With deep sadness, we share the loss of Kaylee Walstad, Chief Strategy Officer of EDRM and an extraordinary advocate, mentor, and friend to so many in the eDiscovery and legal technology community. Kaylee’s generosity, encouragement, and compassion touched countless lives, and her legacy lives on in the people and organizations she lifted.

To honor Kaylee’s remarkable life and lasting contributions, we invite you to share your own memories, reflections, and images. Your tributes will help celebrate the joy she brought to others and the light she shared so freely with everyone she encountered.

  • Enter your email address to receive updates.
  • Click to upload a photo (Max Upload Size 1 MB)
  •  

All Are Welcome