Malpractice Insurance for AI Errors?

Malpractice Insurance for AI Errors?
Image: EDRM.

[EDRM Editor’s Note: The opinions and positions are those of Michael D. Berman.]


“Attorneys may agree on the ethical and professional risks of AI use, but the million-dollar question is whether a lawyer’s general legal malpractice insurance policy will cover AI-related errors. The answer is—to borrow from the profession’s most-used phrase—it depends. But seriously, it depends . . .” —Pamela Langham, Legal Malpractice in the Age of AI | Maryland State Bar Association (Nov. 3, 2026).

Ms. Langham reports that “at least as of September 2026—the date Legal AI Governance published its findings—major legal malpractice carriers do not appear to have adopted a policy provision that specifically excludes AI-related errors, omissions, or malpractice claims from coverage.” [citation omitted].

However, she wrote that other policy clauses may result in a denial of coverage. As one example, if a lawyer cites hallucinated cases without verifying them, an insurer “may take the position that no professional services were rendered. If no professional services were rendered, then there is no coverage.”

The article relies in part on Brian Alenduff, “AI Governance Implementation,” Legal AI Governance, October 28, 2026, https://legalaigovernance.com/about, and reports that:

At renewal time, brokers/underwriters are asking questions about AI usage and application. According to Legal AI Governance, “law firms without documented protocols [for AI use] will fall out of preferred-risk tiers over the next 12-18 months.” In insurance underwriting, a preferred-risk tier is the category reserved for applicants that an insurer views as presenting the lowest likelihood of claims and losses. Because they are considered better risks, policyholders in the preferred-risk tier typically receive the most favorable premiums, broader coverage options, and easier renewals.

Ms. Langham also wrote:

In conclusion, attorneys must now navigate shifting insurance underwriting requirements alongside professional and ethical obligations when using AI. While major legal malpractice insurers have not yet introduced explicit AI exclusions, existing policy provisions regarding misconduct, confidentiality, and unauthorized practice may still leave unmonitored AI errors uncovered. To preserve coverage in preferred-risk tiers for renewals and mitigate potential liabilities, law firms should proactively implement robust AI governance—including formal written policies, vendor due diligence, staff training, and rigorous attorney oversight workflows.

Ms. Langham is a Maryland State Bar Association Legal Content Attorney.


Assisted by GAI and LLM Technologies per EDRM’s GAI and LLM Policy.

Author

  • Michael Berman

    Michael Berman is a practicing lawyer and an adjunct faculty member at the University of Baltimore School of Law.  He has published extensively, including as the editor-in-chief and a contributing author in “Electronically Stored Information in Maryland Courts” (Maryland State Bar Ass’n. 2020), co-editing two American Bar Association books on electronic discovery, as well as co-authoring law review and other articles regarding electronically stored information (“ESI”).  He has presented widely in venues ranging from local to National events and served as a Court Appointed ESI Discovery Supervisor for ESI Protocol.

    View all posts Owner, E-Discovery LLC