
Author: Michael D. Berman
← Back to Blog
Search
Authors
ESI Protocol Did Not Fully Describe a Metadata Privilege Log
In Apex Grp. Capital Advisors LLC v. Related Fund Mgt. LLC, 2026 WL 3258098 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 29, 2026), the parties agreed to a Metadata Privilege Log in their ESI Protocol, but disagreed over its application. ...
Cautionary AI Metadata Decision
It may not be a good thing to leave a metadata trail that confirms AI use. Nugent v. Fortress Flooring, Inc., 2026 WL 3217039 (N.D. Ill. Oct. 27, 2026). The court wrote: “Before addressing the merits...
The “Functional Equivalent” Exception to Waiver of the Attorney-Client Privilege
“Under the functional equivalent doctrine, where a consultant serves as a de facto employee of a company, communications between the consultant and the company’s lawyers are protected by the attorney-client privilege, and disclosure to the...
Malpractice Insurance for AI Errors?
“Attorneys may agree on the ethical and professional risks of AI use, but the million-dollar question is whether a lawyer’s general legal malpractice insurance policy will cover AI-related errors. The answer is—to borrow from the...
An ESI Protocol is Not Rule-Mandated – A “Discovery Plan” Is Mandated
Plaintiff’s civil rights suit against several police officers arose out of his arrest after a traffic stop. Parts of the occurrence were recorded by police cameras. Plaintiff alleged “unlawful prolongation of the stop, unlawful search of...
Sua Sponte Rule 502(d) Order Re Detailed Attorneys’ Billing Records
Plaintiff filed two motions to seal certain evidence supporting its motion for attorney’s fees. Both motions sought to seal partially redacted law firm billing records from Plaintiff’s attorneys. “No objections were filed.” The motions were denied. Rock Spring...
Even With an Error, Expert’s “Troubling” Use of AI as a “Thought Partner” Did Not Undermine Expert Opinion
The defendant in a criminal case sought interlocutory review of an order permitting expert testimony that was “assisted” by artificial intelligence. Her petition for interlocutory review was denied. Gillespie v. The Superior Ct. of San Diego...
“Will Courts Enforce Protective Order Restrictions on AI Use?”
In a recent post, Phil Favro asked Will Courts Enforce Protective Order Restrictions on AI Use? (Favro Law Sep. 29, 2026). I have reviewed a lot of these orders, but Phil’s suggestion is one I...
Negligent Failure to Preserve Does Not Trigger Fed.R.Civ.P. 37(e)(2) Sanctions
In a prior blog, “When Was the Duty to Preserve Triggered in an Employment Dispute?,” I discussed the facts and trigger analysis in Alsayiri v. Crucial MRO, LLC, 2026 WL 3315271 (S.D. Ill. Nov. 3, 2026)....
When Was the Duty to Preserve Triggered in an Employment Dispute?
In this employment litigation, Plaintiff, Mr. Alsayiri, moved for spoliation sanctions and to compel production. The motion was granted in part, after a detailed analysis of when the duty to preserve was triggered. Alsayiri v. Crucial...
Pre-Suit Motion to Preserve Evidence Granted, With a Calculated Risk
General Motors filed a Fed.R.Civ.P. 27 motion to preserve evidence that “could” be involved in an as-yet unfiled lawsuit. The motion centered on parts of a vehicle that had been involved in a fatal collision....
Both Parties Misunderstood the ESI Protocol Regarding Production From Personal Email Accounts
Often, people write what they mean and mean what they write. However, in Flybar, Inc. v. Express Trade Capital, Inc., 2026 WL 3231635 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 28, 2026), “the Court disagrees with both parties’ reading of...
