
Author: Michael D. Berman
← Back to Blog
Search
Authors
Dynamite Discovery Blasted by Court
Courts have a great way of making a point. Plaintiffs call this a fishing expedition. In part, I agree. The subpoenas demand a large share of documents in Plaintiffs’ control for the last ten years....
Honest Error – No Sanctions, But a Penalty
Faced with an honest error in submitting a motion with inaccurate citations, the court did not impose sanctions but held that it would not consider the replacement authorities.
A Beautiful Tribute by the Supreme Court of Arkansas
I don’t live in Arkansas and did not know Professor John L. Cook, but wanted to note a beautiful tribute by the Supreme Court of Arkansas: This October, Professor John Cook passed away following a...
An ESI Protocol is Not a Shield Against Discovery Obligations – Is There a Duty to “Fess Up?” – Part III
Plaintiff’s argument that an ESI Protocol limited its discovery obligations was squarely rejected in CR Legal Team, LLP v. Carruthers & Roth, P.A., 2026 WL 3135943 (M.D. N.C. Oct. 20, 2026). It was insufficient for...
Court Denies Motion to Prohibit Use of GenAI by Opponents
A court recently addressed Defendants’ Joint Motion for an Order Prohibiting the Use of Generative AI. The Defendants relied on Fed. R. Civ. P. 11 and the court’s common-law inherent authority to support their motion...
Privilege Logging an Email String or Thread—Is There a Better Mousetrap?
There are varying schools of thought on how to enter an email string or thread in a privilege log. The “top email only” approach is less expensive, but may run afoul of the “trust, but...
Pro Se Prompts Privileged – N.Y. Court followed Morgan and Warner; Distinguished Heppner
A New York court held that an unrepresented litigant’s use of AI was protected work product. It addressed subpoenas directed to OpenAI seeking a pro se litigant’s use of AI.
When is an In-Person Deposition Warranted? When Credibility of a Fleeing Felon is in Issue
Defendants sought an order compelling an in-person deposition or, in the alternative, dismissal of the case. Plaintiff asked for a virtual deposition. Defendants prevailed.
Improper Reliance on A.I. + Failure to Use Litigation Support Experts + Lack of Transparency = Failure to Comply With “Meet & Confer” Order
After a hearing, the Lighthouse court “issued an interim Order compelling the parties to meet and confer, and to retain an independent third-party electronically stored information (‘ESI’) specialist to assist the parties to effectuate the...
Insurer’s Denial of Coverage for Litigation Costs During Doc Review Justifies Late Assertion of Privilege
Defendants failed to timely assert privilege. Plaintiff claimed waiver. However, because Defendants’ insurance company denied coverage of litigation costs at the time when review of 700,000 documents was to commence, a court held that privilege...
“Contention Interrogatories” Asking for “All” Facts Were Too Broad
Contention interrogatories ask an opponent to state the facts on which it relies to support a specific contention. Fed.R.Civ.P. 33(a)(2) as amended in 1970 states: An interrogatory is not objectionable merely because it asks for an...
The Standard for a Preservation Order
“Plaintiff True Footage Inc. asks the Court to enter an order directing Defendants Automax AI Inc., Automax AI (US) Inc., and Humza Ahmed to preserve evidence. The Court denies Plaintiff’s request.” True Footage Inc. v....
